Sleeping Luxe: Compare Serenity vs Supreme Tempur-Pedic Mattress Toppers

Today we are going to compare two top-quality mattress toppers from Tempur-Pedic, Serenity, and Supreme. We put both of these mattress toppers’ sides by the side to see which is the best.

We found out Tempur-Pedic Supreme has a slight advantage over the Tempur-Pedic Serenity. Let’s see what made Tempur-Pedic Supreme better than Tempur-Pedic Serenity.

Why is Tempur-Pedic Supreme best?

  • Supreme is made with Tempur-Pedic’s premium materials, while  Serenity is made with ordinary foam.
  • It provides you with outstanding body shaping and pain relief meanwhile, you may sink to the serenity mattress topper.
  • The Supreme is made with High-quality materials. It won’t make your body hotter if you sleep for hours. The Serenity is made with local materials and will transfer your body hit back to you.

Well, reading the features mentioned above, you already know the key features that made Tempur-Pedic Supreme better than Tempur-Pedic Serenity. If you want to check the prices and want to get any of these mattress toppers at home, click the buttons below.

[easyazon_link identifier=”B00HEODIZY” locale=”US” nw=”y” nf=”y” tag=”mattrevs16-20″ cart=”n” popups=”n”]Tempur-Pedic Supreme Price[/easyazon_link]

[easyazon_link identifier=”B07DBG18J9″ locale=”US” nw=”y” nf=”y” tag=”mattrevs16-20″ cart=”n” popups=”n”]Tempur-Pedic Serenity Price[/easyazon_link]

Specifications Tempur-Pedic SupremeTempur-Pedic Serenity
Editor’s Rating 4.8 out of 54.4 out of 5 
Available SizesTwin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California KingTwin, Full, Queen, King, California King
Item Weight25-50 lbs21-43 lbs
Thickness3 inches3 inches
WarrantyTen years limited warrantyTen years limited warranty
 [easyazon_link identifier=”B00HEODIZY” locale=”US” nw=”y” nf=”y” tag=”mattrevs16-20″ cart=”n” popups=”n”]Check Price[/easyazon_link][easyazon_link identifier=”B07DBG18J9″ locale=”US” nw=”y” nf=”y” tag=”mattrevs16-20″ cart=”n” popups=”n”]Check Price[/easyazon_link]

Similarities and differences between Tempur-Pedic Serenity and Supreme


The Tempur-Pedic Mattress topper supreme is prepared with the same top-notch premium Tempur material that Tempur-Pedic uses in their expensive and luxurious mattresses. It’s one kind of foam, but not similar to the ordinary foam we use. 

It changes shape according to your body and provides a soft, pain-relieving, and sound sleep. On the other hand,  Tempur-Pedic does not use its premium materials for the Serenity mattress topper. 

It is made with the ordinary foam we use in our homes. It will not give you the luxurious sound sleep you want, but if you have a limited budget, Tempur-Pedic Serenity is still a great choice.


Both Tempur-Pedic Supreme and Serenity come with a thickness of 3 inches. So you can also use it with worn-out mattresses, which improves back spine strength. You can use a Supreme mattress topper on top of hard mattresses. It will give you a soft feeling, and you won’t have to fear back pains. 

Serenity mattress toppers are also useful in their area because you can use them temporarily as a bedsheet. But, I would not recommend it for regular use because you might feel back pain after some days.


The ordinary foams we use at home get hotter with time when we lay on it. But the Tempur-Pedic Supreme is different in this area. It won’t get hotter with time. It will adjust its temperature according to your body’s temperature. It might not make your body cooler, but it won’t make it hotter. So, you will get a sound and seamless sleeping time. 

Meanwhile, the Tempur-Pedic Serenity is not that good compared to the Supreme one, but it still provides a medium feel that will be great for back and side sleepers if they are looking for a softer mattress. This mattress will also benefit people with back or shoulder pain.


The premium material of Tempur-Pedic Supreme helps it to last longer than any ordinary foam without warping and breaking down, common problems we usually face when using cheaper mattress toppers. As a result, you won’t feel uneasy while sleeping and can use it for a long time, whereas Tempur-Pedic Serenity is also good at this. 

If you are a light sleeper and easily get awake feeling any motion, it will help you sleep peacefully. So, both of the mattress toppers can provide you with enough durability, and you can have a deep sleep without even noticing motions.

Additional Uses

Yes, you read it right. You can use these mattress toppers for multi-purposes. While most people use Supreme as a mattress topper, you can also use it on a daybed or even a couch to create a short-term sleeping place for visitors. You can even use it on its own, but not for a long time. 

It may have different sizes, but all sizes will provide you with the same comfort level. Meanwhile, you can use the Serenity mattress topper exactly like the Supreme one. But, The Supreme mattress topper will give you more comfort.

Issues and Limitations

Even though the Tempur-Pedic mattresses are made from premium materials, it still has some drawbacks. Heavy sleepers may not feel well on this mattress topper. Some may find it too soft and won’t like it that much. 

If you use it over soft mattresses, your body will sink to it because it is soft itself. Another limitation is its price. It is one of the best, if not the Best mattress toppers available on the market. So, it is a bit pricey.

As for the Tempur-Pedic Serenity, it is not the finest for hot sleepers. You may feel it too warm if your body releases heat. It captivates the warmth from your body and returns it to you by the tight hug it gives. The breathable cover may help a little, but it is not enough. So, we would not recommend it.


The Tempur-Pedic provides a ten-year limited warranty with both of these mattress toppers. The provided warranty will only be valid if the products are bought new and from authorized resellers. You will not be considered a buyer if you buy it from someone else, not the authorized reseller or Temper-Pedic itself. 

Here the authorized reseller means a shop or an individual who Temper Pedic has authorized to sell the original Tempur-Pedic products to the buyers. If someone buys it from whatever source to resell it at a higher rate will be considered an unauthorized reseller.

You may want to read about the best mattress buying guideline

FAQs about Tempur-Pedic Supreme and Serenity

Will the topper help if a mattress is too soft?

No, the toppers will not help at all if the mattress below it is too soft.

Do you sink through it to your original mattress, or does it seem to hold up and give good support?

Well, it totally depends on the mattress you are using with it. If you are using a hard mattress, then it will definitely provide you with good support.

Is there any chemical smell?

Yes, a bit. But the smell coming from it will vanish in a month or so.

Looking for a soft cushion topper, does Supreme Mattress topper work on a firm mattress?

Yes, it works well with a firm mattress.

Are these the original Tempur-pedic mattress toppers?

Yes, these are original products made by Tempur-Pedic.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top